Meet Our Team

Ashley Reigstad-Pilarowski

Ashley's a former insurance guru who joined Mary's team in 2017. She holds the absolute highest standard for client service, communication, and care with every detail.  She is our go-getter, and with her outstanding and fun personality, our clients just adore her!  While living in Poland (yes, the country!), Ashley attended Lakeland College and obtained her Bachelor of Arts in Accounting(she loves #s but NEEDS customer interaction!). Ashley lives in DeForest with her husband Pawel and their two children, Anna and Roman. When Ashley is not busy with the in’s and outs of real estate you may find her kayaking down the river or camping at the local campgrounds. She can't wait to meet YOU!

Mariah's a lifelong WI resident who grew up in DeForest. She attended the University of Wisconsin-Whitewater where she double- majored in marketing and management. Mariah is a licensed Realtor® who brings a wealth of marketing and customer service experience to the team.  She currently resides in Fort Atkinson with her adorable fur baby named Nola. She’s a sports fan (Go Pack Go!), and a swim coach for the Fort Atkinson Swim Team. In her free time, she enjoys working on her house and exploring different spots in Wisconsin.


Mariah Fitz

Michelle Soter

Michelle brings a wealth of knowledge to our team, along with a fun sense of humor and a love for our wonderful State of Wisconsin!  She started her real estate career closing real estate transactions for a local title company.  Michelle obtained her real estate broker license in 2002 and worked in the commercial real estate field in selling & leasing.  In 2013, she decided a change was in order and started to sell & lease residential real estate.  Michelle wears many hats - she's a property manager AND our certified stager - she's incredibly talented!  Michelle enjoys working with our sellers to provide staging advice. She’ll walk through your home and help stage it for a quick, painless sale.  She focuses on organizing and decluttering, using your own furniture to stage in the best possible way for prospective buyers. She’ll also bring supplemental items such as artwork and throw pillows when needed to really give your house the 'Wow!' factor it needs to impress buyers. Michelle lives in Waterloo with her family and their favorite hunting Lab, Lady.


  • MRP
  • SRES
  • CRS